Women are habitually conditioned to be their own harshest critics, and to hold themselves to impossible standards — which is why when a woman openly and unabashedly says that she is “really beautiful,” it can stir up a whole range of responses.
Recently, The Cut published an article about one woman’s “struggle” with living life as a conventionally beautiful person. The anonymous woman, who is now in her late 50s, described the pitfalls of being attractive to writer Alexa Tsoulis-Reay.
“My looks definitely opened doors for me. I never interviewed for a job I didn’t get” https://t.co/qi1O7MBDp2
— The Cut (@TheCut) April 2, 2018
Naturally, the headline alone was somewhat divisive.
do i dare click pic.twitter.com/WtRpoKoLtl
— rachel syme (@rachsyme) April 2, 2018
However, the contents of the article also stirred up controversy on Twitter.
oh no i clicked pic.twitter.com/oTSvbzInv2
— rachel syme (@rachsyme) April 2, 2018
Many people on Twitter couldn’t help but mock the anonymous woman for her apparent self-involvement and patronizing tone.
— rachel syme (@rachsyme) April 2, 2018
Yeah… this didn’t happen pic.twitter.com/PunUN7qPAK
— Anna Khachiyan (@annakhachiyan) April 2, 2018
that being said, being beautiful sounds amazing
— Elizabeth Bruenig (@ebruenig) April 2, 2018
wow finally my struggles are being seen pic.twitter.com/mv9H7uzAlP
— lucy valentine (@LucyXIV) April 3, 2018
I am grateful that we all learned what it’s like to go through life as a really beautiful woman today
— Danielle Sepulveres (@ellesep) April 3, 2018
However, there were also people who found the piece to be an illuminating and sympathetic exploration of what it’s really like to go through life with a “beautiful” exterior.
Been seeing too many people mock this “what it’s like to be a beautiful woman”, and y’all are horrible humans. Try practicing empathy, cause clearly you didn’t bother to read the piece: pic.twitter.com/NMVIju2x4F
— Hoodie Rebecca ? (@dorothyofisrael) April 2, 2018
Writer Jessica Wakeman acknowledged that the piece itself had flaws, but that the discussion itself is still very important, and deserves to be explored — regardless of the Twitter eye-rolls.
Unpopular opinion (maybe):
That “What It’s Like To Go Through Life As A Really Beautiful Women” piece could have been really good. Maybe not as an as-told-to, though.
Beauty privilege is a topic we need to discuss more.
A lot more.
— Jessica Wakeman (@JessicaWakeman) April 3, 2018
The problem is that when a beautiful woman herself tries to discuss it, she’s automatically accused of being self-involved and oblivious. And you know, people want to see pictures.
When a “regular” women tries to discuss is, she’s accused of being jealous.
— Jessica Wakeman (@JessicaWakeman) April 3, 2018
(And people want to see pictures of her to “prove” it.)
These reactions are damaging, even if they’re well-intentioned. We *KNOW* conventionally attractive people go through life differently — not always more easily, but yes, often that.
— Jessica Wakeman (@JessicaWakeman) April 3, 2018
Studies have shown that conventionally attractive people get hired more. They get more online dating swipes/messages. They are over-represented in film, music, and print media.
— Jessica Wakeman (@JessicaWakeman) April 3, 2018
And everyone *knows* looking more attractive has advantages: money, sex, love, self-esteem, etc. THAT’S WHY THERE ARE BILLION-DOLLAR INDUSTRIES FOCUSED ON “IMPROVING” EVERYTHING ABOUT US.
— Jessica Wakeman (@JessicaWakeman) April 3, 2018
So to dismiss any discussions of beauty privilege, or jealousy, especially amongst women, because it’s too “shallow” or not worthy of serious examination/critique is short-sighted.
— Jessica Wakeman (@JessicaWakeman) April 3, 2018
After perusing the article, it’s highly possible that this woman’s struggles had little to do with her appearance and much more to do with her personality (brazen, confident people have been known to make more than a few enemies). And while the piece may not exactly inspire sympathy, it does encourage a discussion about the privilege surrounding beauty.
Because if being interviewed for an article that has nothing to do with your great accomplishments, remarkable intelligence or striking personality isn’t a privilege, then I don’t know what is.